The Perfect Storm: On Fancy Gap by Zak Jones

Fancy Gap
Zak Jones
Penguin Random House
336 pp., $38.00, 2026

I work in a church basement. The words I use for it—creative programming, food justice—obfuscate the fact that it is not a pretty thing. The brewing of coffee, the stash of clean diapers, the ever-ring call of the stairlift. Not what my absences wanted for me, not what one familiar calls a career job. What it is, or has been, is the opposite of absence. Everything beautiful-ugly about seeing each other again. Teetering in our various crises, whatever the weather is saying today. She repeats: What happened? He repeats: I help people. The creases of who we have been crinkle between us.

The story of a son, a son, a mother, a grandmother, a world coming undone, Fancy Gap is a kind of gospel for the fever pitch of worst-case scenarios.

A block away from my basement, Zak Jones drives by Sal walking the dog, on his way to pick up a friend. Zak Jones has the best vibe, Sal says. He just seems to love his life. Walking up Bathurst another day, Kate says, He just walks the walk. When a volunteer at my job engages me on the question of art vs. artist, I shake my head curtly. It’s the same, I say. It’s the city. Walk into a room; the bios dissolve. What is the internet here? Whom do you love?


What I’m getting to is that Zak Jones’ novel is, in some ways, an inversion of the meeting-corners of the city he makes. That the knowledge of adjacent-room acquaintance—embodied in the length and precision of his novel’s acknowledgments, a record of a life—made reading the novel, for me, ex-Catholic ex-American, bearable. Because Fancy Gap itself is the clap of “a hundred women laughing out of one woman’s mouth,” one woman’s hillside, flames licking at “the speed of prayer” to outrun the pace of the death of America, the turn of the psyche when there is no anchor, when there are no drugs, when there are people in the way of more drugs. When escape is a mudslide into the same mud. When the face is familiar no matter where you go. When it’s your mother’s face. When it’s your mother who’s gone.

The story of a son, a son, a mother, a grandmother, a world coming undone, Fancy Gap is a kind of gospel for the fever pitch of worst-case scenarios (“all the terrible outcomes,” Jones writes to his own mother in his acknowledgments, “from which your love and perseverance saved us”). Its “myriad alternatives”’ flash their skulls in the lightning: a father being a father, a “caring son,” coming home. A brother, now a man, staying, speaking to someone he could have loved. Two boys’ lips, close. Could. Could: Being the type of person your mother wanted you to be. Being the type of person you want to be. Those being the same.

Instead, the novel’s way-things-are is what Trynne and I call “everyone being themself in the chat.” A bag of joints, all hinging in their shaped direction. Leaving, leaving, burning. A surge of inevitability. Even as their directions tear into each other, tearing the joints, tearing the bag.


( In February I thought, God is a word for a pattern. The pattern being “Dalton’s own quiet tones” in the voice of the boy who called Jane the devil, being the “ghost that appears after staring at a lightbulb.” Being the memory of Messiah in “[Dalton’s] eyes,” when “Messiah was in the stream … where Dalton wasn’t.” Being Messiah, naked in another stream, climbing up the storm to Grace, the “green ghost” of Hawk’s face repeating in his own. When Clyde, climbing up the storm to Grace, sees Jane in Grace, sees Grace in everything. “He even brushed his teeth for her, he thought.” The pattern gyres: at the centre, Grace’s end times fabricate themselves, climbing ghosts twisting naked in a thousand streams.

Which is when I think, God is a word for control. Toward the relief of destruction, the seize of an eye, a thousand lifetimes at once—frozen, reaching, the pre-drawn conclusion, “like he could pull energy and focus, somehow, from his resistance to the feeling itself,” the feeling, itself, constricting, tighter and tighter, somewhere where everyone knows you.

At the church potluck where everyone knows her, Jane sits longer, unacknowledged, “holding her stomach. Thinking of her son.” She sits in her car, “hat[ing] to think of that child seeing her for what she worried she was.” Her son, Dalton, walks out of the corner store, avoiding the kid from high school. Hawk shoots. Hawk shoots. To be recognized. Hell, heaven, hell: the truth. )


Jones’ ability to crank the dense turn of short fiction turns, across the chapters of a novel, into an ability to become drenched in anyone. A sick woman’s “much more practiced and much more acceptable” eyebrows, the echoing womp of fatigue in the middle of a grocery store aisle. Each description of each body its own pinching, mortal limitation (except, maybe, for Grace, who “regularly let her spirit run over the meagre cup of her body and onto her followers”). Each voice so total, a kind of authorial tenderness amidst the fray: “It was real redemption, Jane thought, to be so defeated and so saved.”

I needed to hear another voice. Another repetition, another drawl, another word for God.

There is the complete voice of each character, then there is the resonant bellow of preachers, their sentences long and hanging, draping the landscape. A foliage drawl. There is Pastor Hickock speaking of Mary Magdalene, who “wiped away what once was for the terrible promise of what will be”; then there is Grace, “shaking her hands out at the crowd like so many lightning flashes,” the stretch of her throat a bird cry:

We either hasten the end, … or we hasten others to their very real, very assured damnation. … Expel, expel! Expedite! I will bear witness to the soundness of this for you. Who and what you are is a distraction from the who and what you shall be.

The sound of laughter, rain, the red scars, fresh—the churn of voices in the same storm, in Dalton’s chest, my own—no time for relief, reflection, only repetition, propulsion to the building momentum—walking into the basement, over and over—a warrant out for Dalton’s arrest—the police, in the basement, unannounced, asking us if we have seen so and so—

I needed to hear another voice. Another repetition, another drawl, another word for God. In Encampment’s Easter Sermon, Maggie Helwig, too, speaks of Mary Magdalene: “To be called by your name is no small thing.” A word for a god, or a God. This naming, she writes, “begins with our choice to be our own selves once again, the selves we were given in our creation”—no haste or expelling required, no one needed to bear witness to this self’s soundness.


Jones told me he spoke his characters’ sermons aloud then transcribed them, explaining their drumming hypnosis, how their language fills you with language, brings you to words, from the movement of a mouth, to movement. “You got all the words you need,” says Hawk, “to do just what Grace does.” Helwig’s writing, too, much like her life, is spoken, and acted; the work and the work inherently entwined, the city’s book award granted to her encampment book the same day the very same city cleared that very encampment.

There is a person I was once. That person is nowhere in the smell of the basement, the cigarette bucket. The aunt-artist who said, with pride in her chest, I don’t get into politics; I just want to make more beauty. I stomp, I put out sheets of paper. We write. We clean windows. I text my absence, the compost bin looks holy.

Helwig writes of Mary: “She has her name, Mary. And she has her work.” Helwig at her corner, turns to climb the city-placed gates. I turn my corner, down my stairs; Jones turns the corner, blinker on, to his friend. “You must turn,” Helwig writes, “no matter how hard the turning”: to your work. Named, “changed, … knowing good and evil, and more evil than we wish.” I tell Sal, Zak Jones has lived lifetimes before this. His love is the full-belly relief of arrival. “Power and greed and fear will try to stop you,” writes Helwig. Someone else’s word will try to expedite you. “Time and grief will wear you down.” But life, the long trudge to the unpretty thing, “stands with you,” drives you past, walks your dog, lights the fire, climbs the fence, “speaks your name,” “wakes with me”1 “in the morning.”

1 The quotes in this paragraph all come from Helwig’s “Encampment,” other than this one, which is pulled from the end of Jones’ acknowledgements.

About the author

EJ Kneifel is a poet and community arts programmer. Their programming interests stem from the ways repetitive gathering naturally leads to release. Most recently, at The Stop Community Food Centre, this meant a five month weekly poetry-group-turned-songwriting-workshop and community gathering/performance. This Fall, EJ will be running an ESL class through Parkdale Project Read which builds on principles of Augusto Boal's Theatre of the Oppressed/Forum Theatre.