What’s Mine is Yours: Kate Cayley’s Property
This place is small. If you can’t stand beside someone you don’t know, please leave. This is what’s written on a scrap of paper that hangs on the wall of a cramped music venue blocks from my Winnipeg apartment.
I thought of this sign several times while reading Kate Cayley’s Property. Not set in a bar at all, the novel takes place almost entirely on one residential street in Toronto. Over the course of a single day, Cayley burrows deep into the minds of several of the street’s residents, meditating on the devastating effort of numerous relationships that, externally, do not mirror each other: woman and wife, man and work, rat and hole, and so on.
The book’s synopsis promises a death before the end of the day. More than just morbid curiosity, though, it’s Cayley’s command of pace and person that propels the book forward. Time passes as it does in real life. Some hours lurch like a dog lunging for a squirrel. Neurotic spells scatter to the tempo of radio jazz. There are moments of pause that pour like wine and moments of pain that leak like piss. Doom stalks each character from the very first page.
Property delivers such an all-consuming story that I found myself in each character’s skin. Disturbed by the fit, but oddly comforted by the undoable companionship.
The novel’s characters feel so real that I found myself looking for them in my own neighbourhood for weeks after I finished the final chapter. Looking for Maddy in the grocery store; for Ilya in a puddly and abandoned construction site; for Nat in the mirror.
In one scene, Nat prepares pulled pork in her newly renovated kitchen. She ruminates on the apocalypse; the dead woman who used to live in her house; her marriage; her teenage son’s overgrown toenails. What she needs and what needs her. She’s just like me, I thought.
Am I married? No. Do I have a son? No. Do I own property in Toronto? Of course not. Nonetheless, Property delivers such an all-consuming story that I found myself in each character’s skin. Disturbed by the fit, but oddly comforted by the undoable companionship.
This dis/comfort is reflected in Nat’s relationship with her neighbour, Maddy. She cannot call Maddy her friend. She will not allow herself to relate to her. There is no way Nat—with her liberal arts education, working class background, and loving wife, Frankie (whom she imagines as a child was “embryonically butch”)—could have anything in common with Maddy—the “preternaturally immaculate” actress next door, straight and shallow, with her pathetic children and boring husband.
To Nat, Maddy is an amusing character she can tell her real friends about when they call. The book’s omniscient narrator alludes to a resemblance between the two women that Nat works to ignore: “If the actual details of Nat’s days closely resembled Maddy’s, the old friends didn’t point it out.”
Still, Nat’s days are built upon, or leaning against, Maddy’s existence. They make dinner plans. Their young and unnerving daughters are best friends, hand in bloody hand. To remove Maddy from her life would threaten its structural integrity.
When an incident occurs between their children and blame is cast, the mothers are quick to defend their own offspring—wrenching the two households apart. They retreat to their separate properties, to their own kin. But what about their dinner plans? It will be so awkward to eat together now, but the meal is already prepared.
“Do you still want us to come tonight?” Maddy asks, desperate as ever. In the interaction that follows, the women seem to play a type of emotional chicken. They wait for the other to crack. To stand in the middle of their shared street and scream, I want you in my life!
Next door, Ilya, a young construction worker, labours alone on the hopeless foundation of an excavated home. The property is unoccupied—its neglectful owner, annoyed by the burden of his assets, lets Ilya’s calls go to voicemail.
Cayley’s writing doesn’t waver. In just a few pages, she constructs deep-rooted histories, relationships, and homes for even the story’s minor characters.
Ilya’s hours of work result in little progress. A sump pump whirs in vain. The home was built, long ago, atop a river that will outlive the whole block. Here, rats frolic, unconcerned by the wants and worries of the humans above—“almost as indifferent,” Cayley writes, “as the water to whatever stands between them and their path.”
The book is divided not by chapters but by morning, afternoon, and evening. Some characters steer the narration for a paragraph or so, while others dominate up to twenty pages at a time. This rhythm manufactures a certain frustration: I felt whisked away from a character before I could construct my own image of them, outside of the one informed by their neighbours’ remarks.
The passages that look most closely at Ilya describe a man soggy with shame. Heavy shoulders, scarred hands, trauma personified—not exactly a hunk. But Nat sees a tatted chain smoker. Juvenile and masculine. And Maddy sees a sensitivity in Ilya that matches her own. She harbors a simple attraction to him, considers it an escape from her current life of monotonous marriage and motherhood. An affair as effective an exit strategy as a call from her agent or a mental breakdown that lands her a case with social services.
Cayley’s writing doesn’t waver. In just a few pages, she constructs deep-rooted histories, relationships, and homes for even the story’s minor characters. Like the elderly woman across the street, who lies at the bottom of her staircase, unable to get up after a fall. She’s afraid, mostly, of her adult son who still lives with her. Disabled since birth, he spends most of his time holed up in his room making menacing noises or lurking around the block, mumbling to himself. He is the neighbourhood's cautionary tale. Children are told to cross the street to avoid him.
The old woman waits for the news that her son has hurt someone. Waits for that someone to be herself. While her son’s eventual return is her only chance of rescue, she can only imagine how he might treat her when he discovers her in such a helpless position.
Another woman, a few doors down, smokes while her intimidating but aging dog sleeps at her feet. The Rolling Stones blare from her speakers all day long, the dog yelping occasionally to add to the volume. She holds seniority on the block, even if she is the only one to recognize it. She remembers a time before all the young families moved in, a time “when almost everyone spoke Portuguese.” She does not apologize when her dog gnashes at the nosey children. She doesn’t bat an eye as Nat glares at her from across the street.
Here, this book about one day turns out to be a book about life writ large; how often do we get so caught up in the moment that we forget about death, the one thing promised to us from the very beginning?
Toward the end of the book, in the midst of a surprisingly copacetic dinner between Nat and Maddy’s families, I remember that one character will soon be dead. During dinner, the food is perfect, the children are well behaved, and Nat finds herself full of a happiness she can’t explain. She even takes a rare break from fretting over her troubled son, wherever he is. “Later, she recalls this,” Cayley writes, immediately after describing the blissful meal, “with a shame so great she can’t tell anyone, not even Frankie, when they sit up in bed trying to make sense of the night.”
This line felt like Cayley winking at me from her own spot at the table. Nat was distracted by the dinner, and, apparently, so was I. Here, this book about one day turns out to be a book about life writ large; how often do we get so caught up in the moment that we forget about death, the one thing promised to us from the very beginning?
The book's final pages divulge what becomes of each character after this one momentous day. What could feel like cloying solutions are cut with Cayley’s consistent bluntness. The future will see freedom and vulnerability; peace and resentment. The story is tied with a bow and barbed wire.
Property is not a novel that preaches to love thy neighbour or tolerate thy roommate. In its sobriety, it feels like required reading for anyone in proximity to others. Whether sharing a bed or a block or one habitable planet with another person, we learn to stand beside those who will never fully be known to us. We choose to exist in this need and unknowing, day after day. Meanwhile, there is work. And dogs. And dinner.

